Where in Florida Are New Yorkers Moving To?

The Great Migration South

Over the past several years, a powerful migration trend has reshaped Florida’s housing market: thousands of New Yorkers are heading south in search of a better lifestyle, lower taxes, and more sunshine. According to U.S. Census migration data and moving company reports, New York has consistently ranked among the top states losing residents to Florida.

While familiar names like Miami, Tampa, and Orlando often dominate the headlines, there’s another city rising in desirability among discerning buyers—Naples, Florida. Known for its refined charm, strong community values, and unmatched Gulf Coast beauty, Naples has quietly become one of the most coveted destinations for former New Yorkers seeking sophistication and serenity.

Why Are New Yorkers Moving to Florida?

The motivations behind this migration are clear—and compelling:

• No State Income Tax: Florida’s lack of personal income tax is a significant draw for high-earning professionals, retirees, and entrepreneurs leaving high-tax states like New York.
  
  

• Lower Cost of Living: Property taxes, utilities, and groceries tend to cost less, allowing residents to enjoy more for less.
  
  

• Year-Round Sunshine: With over 230 sunny days annually, Florida’s climate is the antidote to long, gray New York winters.
  
  

• Remote Work Freedom: The rise of remote work allows professionals to trade skyscrapers for palm trees—without sacrificing career opportunities.
  
  

• Lifestyle and Well-Being: Access to outdoor recreation, wellness amenities, and coastal living promotes a healthier, more balanced lifestyle.
  
  

In short, New Yorkers are seeking both financial freedom and personal rejuvenation—and Florida delivers both.

Where Are Most New Yorkers Moving to in Florida?

While the Sunshine State offers countless desirable destinations, several cities have become migration hotspots for former New Yorkers.

1. Palm Beach County

West Palm Beach, Boca Raton, and Delray Beach have long attracted wealthy New Yorkers, offering upscale shopping, cultural events, and beach proximity. The area’s mix of cosmopolitan flair and coastal charm feels familiar yet relaxed.

2. Miami and Fort Lauderdale

For younger professionals and those who thrive on nightlife, Miami remains a top choice. Its international airport, art scene, and luxury real estate market offer urban sophistication with a tropical twist. Fort Lauderdale provides a slightly quieter lifestyle with easy access to Miami.

3. Tampa Bay Area

Tampa and St. Petersburg appeal to professionals and families seeking affordability, strong job growth, and cultural attractions. The area’s downtown renaissance and sports culture add vibrancy.

4. Sarasota and Bradenton

These Gulf Coast cities blend arts, beaches, and community living, making them attractive to retirees and remote professionals alike. Sarasota’s cultural scene often reminds New Yorkers of home—just sunnier.

5. Orlando and Lake Nona

Beyond theme parks, Orlando has grown into a hub for tech, healthcare, and innovation. The Lake Nona master-planned community has even drawn healthcare executives and athletes looking for world-class amenities.

6. Naples – The Rising Star

While not always at the top of mass migration lists, Naples, FL, has quietly emerged as one of the most desirable relocation destinations for New Yorkers seeking sophistication, exclusivity, and long-term value.

Naples was named one of the best places to live in the United States, earning the #6 spot on U.S. News & World Report’s 2023–2024 list. This recognition highlights Naples’ outstanding quality of life, breathtaking coastal beauty, and strong sense of community that continues to attract new residents from across the country.

Why Naples, FL, Is Becoming the Preferred Destination for New Yorkers

New Yorkers are drawn to Naples for the same reasons they love Manhattan—fine dining, luxury shopping, and cultural vibrancy—but with the benefits of a serene coastal environment. Naples represents elegant living without the chaos.

Here’s why this Gulf Coast paradise is turning heads.

1. Refined, Small-Town Luxury

Naples combines the upscale feel of the Hamptons with the friendliness of a close-knit coastal town. Fifth Avenue South and Third Street South offer chic boutiques, world-class restaurants, and art galleries reminiscent of Soho—but under palm trees.

2. High-End Real Estate

From beachfront estates to new luxury communities like Grey Oaks, Pelican Bay, and Mediterra, Naples offers some of the most sought-after real estate in Florida. Waterfront homes with direct Gulf access are particularly appealing to former New Yorkers accustomed to exclusivity and privacy.

3. Safety and Community

Naples is consistently ranked among the safest cities in Florida. Its clean streets, community events, and sense of civic pride appeal to families and retirees alike.

4. Top-Tier Dining and Culture

With fine dining rivaling New York’s culinary scene, Naples offers restaurants helmed by renowned chefs, a thriving arts district, and the Naples Philharmonic at Artis–Naples for cultural immersion year-round.

5. Nature and Wellness Lifestyle

Beyond luxury, Naples promotes wellness through outdoor living—think kayaking in the mangroves, golfing at championship courses, or catching a sunset on Vanderbilt Beach. This slower, sun-filled rhythm is what many New Yorkers crave after years of high-speed city life.

Comparing Naples to Other Florida Cities

Naples stands apart for combining luxury and tranquility, a rare balance that resonates with those seeking both refinement and relaxation.

The New York to Naples Lifestyle Shift

Many New Yorkers describe their move to Naples as a “reset.” Instead of battling traffic, harsh winters, and crowded subways, they wake up to Gulf breezes and morning walks on white-sand beaches.

The city’s real estate market reflects this growing demand. According to recent Florida housing data, Collier County—home to Naples—has experienced steady value appreciation, particularly in luxury properties. Unlike transient tourist areas, Naples attracts year-round residents, making it ideal for long-term investment.

From Manhattan executives now managing remote portfolios on their lanai to retirees finally trading skyscrapers for sunsets, Naples represents not just a move—but a lifestyle upgrade.

Tips for New Yorkers Considering a Move to Naples, FL

If you’re a New Yorker thinking about relocating to Naples, here are a few insights to make the transition seamless.

• Visit During Peak Season: Experience Naples between December and April to understand its vibrant seasonal energy.
  
  

• Explore Neighborhoods: Communities in Millionaires Row, Park Shore, Talis Park,  Aqualane Shores and many others, each of which offers unique character and amenities.
  
  

• Consider HOA Communities: Many gated neighborhoods include golf, tennis, or club memberships, adding value and community engagement.
  
  

• Work With a Local Expert: A knowledgeable Naples Realtor can guide you through local regulations, taxes, and property nuances.
  
  

Naples: Florida’s Best-Kept Secret for New Yorkers

For those leaving New York, Naples represents the perfect blend of luxury, leisure, and long-term livability. It’s less about escape and more about elevation—of lifestyle, environment, and well-being.

While Miami may attract headlines and Palm Beach holds its pedigree, Naples is quietly redefining what it means to “live well” in Florida. Its real estate market continues to grow in prestige, offering exceptional investment potential and a community that embraces newcomers with warmth.

If you’re ready to trade skyscrapers for sunsets and stress for serenity, Naples awaits with open arms and pristine beaches.

Contact The Whitcomb Group – Naples’ Trusted Real Estate Experts

Stan and Scott Whitcomb, founding partners of The Whitcomb Group, are third-generation professionals in real estate sales, building, and development. Born in Florida and raised in Naples, they are true natives who embody the spirit of Southwest Florida living.

The top Naples realtor team's genuine love for Naples, paired with deep area knowledge, allows them to provide clients with an insider’s perspective on the best neighborhoods, lifestyle opportunities, and investment potential. Stan and Scott take pride in fostering friendships, guiding newcomers, and helping buyers fall in love with Naples the way they have for decades.

Whether you’re considering a relocation from New York or searching for your forever home by the Gulf, The Whitcomb Group offers the professionalism, local insight, and personal connection that make all the difference.

We’d love to connect and share why working with The Whitcomb Group is one of your best decisions.

Contact The Whitcomb Group today to begin your Naples journey with the experts who know it best.

FAQ’s

Q1: Why are so many New Yorkers moving to Florida?
A: Many New Yorkers are relocating to Florida for the warm climate, no state income tax, lower cost of living, and improved quality of life. The Sunshine State also offers more space, outdoor recreation, and financial advantages that appeal to both retirees and remote professionals.

Q2: Is Naples, Florida, a good place for New Yorkers to move?
A: Yes. Naples is one of the best Florida cities for New Yorkers seeking luxury, safety, and community. It offers upscale dining, pristine beaches, world-class golf, and a relaxed coastal lifestyle—ideal for those leaving the fast pace of New York City.

Q3: How does Naples compare to Miami or Palm Beach for New Yorkers?
A: Naples offers a quieter, more refined atmosphere than Miami or Palm Beach. While those cities attract nightlife and high-energy crowds, we are not saying Naples does not have nightlife; it most definitely does. However, tranquility, wellness, and town elegance make it a favorite for professionals and retirees seeking sophistication without the hustle.

Q4: Who are the best Realtors in Naples for New Yorkers relocating?
A: Stan and Scott Whitcomb of The Whitcomb Group are highly respected Naples Realtors and third-generation real estate professionals. Born and raised in Naples, they provide unmatched local expertise and insider guidance for anyone moving from New York to Southwest Florida.